Is Deep Brain Stimulation for Parkinson's recommended or not?

Submitted by PatientsEngage on 24 June 2016

Dr. Pettarusp Wadia Consultant Neurologist and Movement Disorder Specialist, Jaslok Hospital and Research Centre, Mumbai weighs in on when Deep Brain Stimulation treatment for Parkinson's Disease is a recommended choice and what factors you should consider before making a decision. 

Deep Brain Stimulation(DBS) in Parkinson's disease is recommended when 

  1. The patient has a confirmed diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease –
    • fits UKPDS brain bank criteria
    • The patient should ideally be at least 4-5 years in his/her illness to exclude the possibility of missing other disorder which may mimic Parkinson's disease in the early stages.
  2. The quality of life of a patient is affected despite best medical care.
  3. The disabling symptoms improve with L DOPA (Syndopa or Sinemet). The best ON response determines the benefit from DBS

Here is a case study of Hari who underwent DBS treatment for his Parkinson's Disease

When is DBS not recommended?

1. Very old patients – usually 75 and above for STN DBS

2. Significant cognitive issues – i.e. significant memory impairment

3. Significant psychiatric issues especially depression

4. Symptoms that do not respond to L Dopa (Syndopa or Sinemet) which are the reason to consider DBS

What factors would help a family decide if its appropriate for the patient in their family

  1. Disease duration
  2. Confirmed diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease
  3. Response to L Dopa
  4. Poor quality of life despite adequate medical treatment
  5. Good cognition
  6. Absence of significant psychiatric issues
  7. Lastly the DECISION if the patient is a candidate for surgery should be taken by the NEUROLOGIST after appropriate evaluation rather than the neurosurgeon.

What skill sets should the family look for

  1. A centre with experience in performing DBS
  2. That has a team with a trained stereotactic or functional neurosurgeon
  3. A trained movement disorder neurologist on the team

Is DBS the same as Stem Cell Therapy?

No – DBS involved stimulating the brain using electrodes implanted in the brain. 

Stem cells are cells which are aimed to produce dopamine in the brain – however this is still in research and not recommended for clinical use.

Stem cell therapy is NOT APPROVED FOR CLINCAL USE. It is only a research tool.

Is DBS more advanced and safe?

Deep brain stimulation surgery has completed more than 20 years in the world. It is approved by all regulatory authorities across the world and there is CLASS 1 evidence to recommend the same to the above subset of patients.

DBS is not without its share of risks. There are risks primarily that if an infection or a risk of brain haemorrhage when implanting the electrodes.

  

Rigorous exercise may slow Parkinson's Disease progression

 

Community
Neurological Conditions
Parkinsons Disease and Movement Disorder PDMDS
Condition
Parkinson Disease
Changed
Fri, 11/03/2017 - 16:05

Stories

  • Kathak Dance aids mobility of Parkinson’s and Arthritis patients
    Vonita Singh from Dubai is a trained Kathak dancer who, through her unique initiative Movement Mantra, addresses the basic concerns of Parkinson’s Disease like balance, flexibility and coordination with rhythm and music. Vonita also pulls in caregivers for her programmes, making it holistic, with end results being therapeutic. Taking on disorders like Parkinson’s Disease and Arthritis is a formidable task, especially when you are neither a therapist nor a medical person. What gave you the…
  • Household Tips to Ease Arthritis
    Dr S M Akerkar, Consulting Rheumatologist, offers some useful tips for people with arthritis to get work done at home the easier way and to minimize the load on the joints. This is the second of the 2-part series. In the first part we read useful day to day tips on arranging the kitchen to make it easier for people with arthritis to continue to function.  How to arrange your kitchen if you have arthritis? Use shelves with 'easy to remove' features. Drawers mounted on rollers put less…
  • Event : Living with Parkinson's
    We invite you to 'Living with Parkinson's' an event for people with Parkinson's and their caregivers.  Dance & Movement Therapy followed by tips on living with Parkinson's by eminent Neurologist Dr. Manoj Hunnur Date: 27th December, Tuesday Address: Prabodhankar thackeray multipurpose hall, A wing, 2nd floor, Borivali west Timing: 10.30am to 1.30pm  
  • My 3.5 Years of Journey with Parkinson’s!
    Gargi Ahluwalia is immensely grateful to the Support Group of Parkinson's Disease and Movement Disorder Society, (PDMDS), that helped her claim her independence over the debilitating disease. I started trembling from January 2013 when my husband was hospitalised. Four months later, when he passed away, my situation became worse. I thought it was due to stress, not realizing that it was more than that. I spoke to my family doctor and he said that I should see a Neurologist who specialized in…
  • Journey from Negative to Positive through Dance Movement Therapy
    Restoring self-esteem and self-worth is what Dance Movement Therapy by Renelle Snelleksz has successfully achieved for a cross section of people like people with Parkinson’s Disease or those with a history of physical abuse and even children who have survived cancer but are deeply scarred. What is Dance Movement Therapy? How is it different from learning Dance? Dance Movement Therapy (DMT) is very different from technique-based dance in that it creates a safe and non-judgemental space for…
  • Dental Care for the Elderly
    Dental needs become increasingly specialized with age, making regular visits to the dentist even more important. Dr Shail Jaggi highlights some common gum and teeth problems that could become burdensome, if ignored. When we think of an elderly patient the first vision that generally tends to flash by is someone with greying hair, stooping and bent over with age, thick glasses and a denture to eat! But let’s take a quick look at my office! I am dentist and deal with geriatric patients all the…
  • Humans of Parkinsons story - Mr. Suryanarayan
    "I have been a stenographer, an advocate and have obtained a degree in information technology. It has been five years since I have retired. My left hand had started giving me a lot of trouble, and was not obeying my commands. It was then diagnosed that I had Parkinson's. I live alone, and I try to focus on not being limited by anyone, and try my best to not limit others too. I have a responsibility towards myself, and I focus on that. My daily routine is very active and I like it that way…
  • Nutrition in Parkinson’s Disease
    Most of us know that Parkinson’s disease is a neurological disorder that affects our body movement. The disease progresses slowly and gradually the quality of life is affected. The rate of progression generally varies from person to person and is very individualized. As is the case with most diseases, medication is prescribed to control the progression of the disease. Nutrition is particularly important in Parkinson’s disease for many reasons:  The disorder itself slows transition through…
  • A Parkinsons Support Group Meeting in India
    What is a Parkinson's Support Group?
    Support Group for Parkinson's in India run by PDMDS and in collaboration with their partners. Last Update - Feb 2019 A support group is an informal gathering of people who share similar experiences, situations or problems. By meeting together, Parkinson’s Support Group members can offer each other emotional and practical support. In such a group, one is able to learn about Parkinson’s its problems and treatment. But most importantly the members share experiences and practical tips on living…
  • An elderly person on a wheelchair looking out to the lake with a male caregiver standing next to him
    20 Tips For Handling Hospital Stays and Medical Emergencies
    Sangeeta is a blogger who instills rare insight into her role of a caregiver. She not only chronicles the various methods which work for her father, who has Parkinson's, Dementia and Diplopia, but she backs it up with profound logic and common sense. The best part of her blog is her all-pervading humour which gives such a bitter sweet taste to her snippets of caregiving. Here are her top tips for handling medical emergencies and hospital stays.  My father  Anna was in a hospital for…