Skip to main content
Submitted by PatientsEngage on 14 May 2022

Patients with advanced cancers often contemplate the time burden of their cancer care. What does this exactly entail? Dr Arjun Gupta, an Oncologist and Researcher, recently wrote a paper about Time Toxicity for Cancer patients. He helps us understand this new concept and how it can affect quality of life for patients.

What is ‘’time toxicity’’?

We have seen tremendous progress in oncology in the past few decades. Yet, for advanced solid cancers, average survival benefits offered by new treatments are usually in the order of weeks or a couple of months.

The amount of time spent in pursuing cancer treatments can be substantial. Time is spent in frequent visits to clinic, for labs, for scans, for infusions, to see the doctor, the travel and parking time, time in waiting rooms, the time spent on hold with the annoying insurance company, the time spent in the ER, in a 3- day hospitalization. Time is also spent by care partners driving and waiting with patients, taking time off work, the time with schedulers on the phone. All this adds up. This is what we term ‘’the time toxicity of cancer treatment’’.

Why is it important?

We have demonstrated that for some treatments-- the loss of time incurred receiving such treatments may be more than the modest survival gains offered by the treatment.

Time toxicity is most applicable to people with advanced cancer who face treatment decisions in the context of limited time. Patients want to know where and how they will spend their time, not just how much time they might gain.

How can time toxicity guide informed decision making?

Consider Ms. S, a 80-year-old woman, a retired nurse, a loving grandmother. She has been diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. She knows her time is limited. Her goals are to maximize time at home and spending time with her grandchildren. She needs to decide between chemo or no chemo.

She will view treatment differently if she knew that on average, 4 of her 8 months alive would be spent away from home (e.g., in infusions and in the hospital) if she received chemo, but that all of her 6 months alive would be spent at home if she pursued no chemo.

Currently, trials in oncology do not report time toxicity. Clinicians lack information to guide patients on choices.

What are the measures of time toxicity?

The measure we propose is ‘’days with physical health care system contact’’. Any day in which a patient has any contact with the health care system, whether that be for a 30-minute blood draw, a 3-hour procedure, a 6-hour chemotherapy infusion, a 12-hour visit to the urgent care center, or an overnight stay in the hospital is treated the same. It's a day with physical health care system contact. We recognize that not all of these are the same but for the patient and their care partner, these often represent an entire day’s loss.

As a corollary, days not spent with health care contact are home days. So, in essence, overall survival, or the time from diagnosis to death, is nothing but the sum total of ‘’time toxicity’’ or days with health care system contact, and ‘’home days.’’

This metric recognizes that oncology care is delivered in multiple settings. It's delivered in frequent trips to the outpatient clinics and infusion centers, and patients often require inpatient admissions for rest and rehabilitation. It is practical and can easily be measured.

There are a couple of things that we need to keep in mind while thinking about this metric. The first is that people with cancer are often sick because of underlying cancer, and health care system contact by itself is not a bad thing. We need to separate the additional time imposed by a specific cancer treatment over and above the time toxicity of cancer itself. Second, we need to keep in mind that decreased health care contact or decreased time toxicity could represent poor access to care and could widen disparities in health care access.

Ideally, clinical trials should report time toxicity of treatments, and these can be compared across treatments.

In your opinion, what should be the way forward for clinicians and patients?

The main thing missing from the time toxicity science right now are data— data on time toxicity. Clinical trials currently do not report the time toxicity of treatments. That is essential information for clinicians to have, to be able to discuss treatment options with patients including the impact of time toxicity. We are working towards this aim.

The entire article is cited below:

Gupta A, Eisenhauer EA, Booth CM. The Time Toxicity of Cancer Treatment. J Clin Oncol. 2022 Mar 2:JCO2102810. doi: 10.1200/JCO.21.02810.

Bio:

Dr. Arjun Gupta is an Assistant Professor at the University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, USA. He is a gastrointestinal oncologist, a symptom management enthusiast, and a health services researcher. His research specifically examines cancer care access and delivery, the costs of cancer care, and the hidden burdens imposed on and faced by people with cancer and their caregivers while receiving this care.

Community
Condition
Changed
Sat, 05/14/2022 - 20:18

Stories

  • A panel of side effects of chemotherapy
    Real Experiences Of The Side Effects Of Chemotherapy
    Hair Loss is one of the more dreaded side effects of chemotherapy. But thats not the only side effect. Our contributors shared the other side effects they went through. Often the side effects were different in each cycle.  Here is a compilation of the various side effects experienced by our contributors. There have been a few who had no major side effects apart from hair loss. This article can help other patients and their families be prepared for these side-effects. Click on the name to…
  • I Had To Live And Fight My Osteosarcoma For My Son
    A diagnosis of Osteosarcoma (Bone Cancer) when she was 26 years old changed Neema's life forever. She talks of her challenging journey including multiple surgeries, amputation and more and the person who motivated her to fight the cancer. Please tell us a bit about your condition It was November of 1998 when I was just 26 years old. I was diagnosed with Osteosarcoma (bone cancer) of my knee. What were the early symptoms? What made you go see a doctor? I used to work at a Research lab where I…
  • My Brain Tumour Diagnosis Made Me Bold
    When A Chitra, 38 from Bengaluru started having seizures, she was initially treated for epilepsy but was eventually diagnosed with Malignant Glioma, a type of brain tumour. She shares how she handled the gamut of treatment and the emotional distress with the support of her team of doctors, family and friends and employer.  Chitra, please tell us a bit about your condition  I was diagnosed with brain tumour called Anaplastic Astrocytoma Grade III. It is a rare, malignant tumour…
  • Why Cancer Patients Need Counselling
    Ms.Bincy Mathew is a psycho-oncologist, currently working with HCMCT-Manipal Hospitals, New Delhi. She talks about the importance of counselling for cancer patients and their families who are dealing with their psycho-social issues.  What is the role of Psycho-oncology or psychosocial oncology in Cancer care? It is not a myth that cancer brings a lot of emotional and psychological burden on patient’s and caregiver's lives. The fact is, most people are not prepared to face such unexpected…
  • Post Mastectomy Breast Prosthesis - Importance and Options
    Dr. Rohini Patil, a gynaecologist and a 17 year breast cancer survivor from Nagpur was shocked at the lack of awareness about breast prosthesis after mastectomy. She decided to do something about it. Tell us a little about how Knitted Knockers Nagpur  came into being. India is seeing an increase in the incidence of cancer, more worrisome is its increase incidence in the younger population. In India 1 in 22 women have a life time risk of getting diagnosed with Breast Cancer, this is…
  • Need for Holistic Management of Cancer Pain
    Cancer pain can be treated and quality of life in a cancer patient can be enhanced by appropriate medications, emphasise Dr Mary Abraham, Pain & Palliative Care Physician, and Dr Vandana V Prakash, Clinical Psychologist. Despite increased attention to cancer pain, it still continues to be a major issue with cancer patients and survivors. Why is it so? There are many reasons why cancer pain is still a major issue with cancer patients and survivors. Firstly, there is a misconception and fear…
  • After Cancer I Started Concentrating on the NOW
    Pranay Rangra, 35 from Mumbai, is a Stage 2 Non Hodgkin’s Lymphoma survivor shares the psycho-social aspects of life after cancer, how cancer has changed his life. And his future plans, including making a documentary on South Africa.  We spoke to Pranay Rangra on a wide range of topics during the webinar Living Better After Cancer: Adapting to the New Reality. Here are some of the points we spoke about.  How did you deal with work colleagues and friends visiting I was very clear…
  • A picture of a tree taken by a person with  visual impairment
    Photography For Therapy And Self Esteem
    On World Photography Day, we share how photography has provided therapeutic benefit to cancer patients of all ages, helped increased self esteem and self confidence and stimulated emotions and intellect of the visually impaired.  Geetha Paniker, a breast cancer survivor, shares her views on how various forms of creating art, and even photography, can heal both the mind and the body. I truly believe that photography is an incredibly powerful therapy to heal oneself. It is a passion that…
  • A selfie pic of a young woman in a black and red checked shirt and a camera bag strap visible around her neck
    "I Am Hopeful Of A Cure For This Rare Tumor"
    Rima Roy is a young woman of 22 and suffers from a rare condition of Giant Cell Tumors in the Sacram. She shares the emotional toll the diagnosis took on her and how she has come to terms with this rare condition. Describe yourself, Rima I am a warrior in the battlefield of rare disease since I was 19 When were you diagnosed? 19/04/2016. X-ray of the Lumbo- Sacral Spines AP/ LAT views revealed Transitional vertibrae: D12 having rudimentary ribs & L5 sacralized. Then on 14/03/2018 the…
  • Profile pic of a middle aged man in a partially visible grey and white striped shirt
    Faith And Support Are Important When A Family Member Is Affected By Cancer
    Dipanwita Mukherjee was a small girl when her father Bibhuti Bhusan Chakraverty was diagnosed with throat cancer. This is his story, how he overcame his condition and also how he reached out to many others to alleviate their pain. A recent Bengali film, Kontho, based on Mr Chakraverty’s life and struggles has also brought the story back in focus. When was your father diagnosed with throat cancer? My father, late Bibhuti Bhusan Chakraverty was detected with throat cancer in the year 1972. He was…